“They told us they didn’t have good news,” said one man who was at the briefing. “Everybody is stunned and sick to our stomachs. We feel like we’ve been lied to, we’ve been lied to all along … This is probably the most horrible thing that’s ever happened to me in my lifetime.”
Late last evening, the story out of West Virginia was being described as a miracle: 12 workers trapped in Sago Mine survived 41 hours underground, despite high levels of carbom monoxide and the discovery of a body closer to the mine entrance. Early this morning, something unthinkable had happened to that story. A horrible mistake had been made: there weren’t 12 survivors, there were 12 dead.


People cling tightly to stories of hope. In the aftermath of the September 11 attack on the World Trade Center towers, rumours and wild stories surfaced about people who had survived against the odds. One such story that I’ve never forgotten involved a man who managed to walk away from the collapse of one of the towers by surfing on a wave of rubble as the tower came down. It’s the sort of story that, in earlier times, might have become a legend: an ordinary man performing an unthinkable feat in the face of overwhelming horror. It was also the sort of story that couldn’t possibly be true, except that it very well might have been.
But people also remember stories like this one, the exact opposite of the man who fell to earth and lived. It’s almost too perfect in its reversal of fortune, in the way it has stripped an entire community so thoroughly of the belief that they had been spared. Few stories have a final act so cruel and devastating as this, and Tallmansville is doubly stricken for it.